Religion

Is Character Assassination a Christian Virtue?

Will Hinton's picture

It appears that Pastor Roger Byrd of Jonesville, SC thinks so. I read this article today about a sign that Byrd placed in front of his church.

It reads: "Obama, Osama, hmm, are they brothers?"

Byrd then goes on to explain....actually, he goes on to lie about why he put the sign up.

Byrd said that the message wasn't meant to be racial or political.

"It's simply to cause people to realize and to see what possibly could happen if we were to get someone in there that does not believe in Jesus Christ," he said.

When asked if he believes that Barack Obama is Muslim, Byrd said, "I don't know. See it asks a question: Are they brothers? In other words, is he Muslim ? I don't know. He says he's not. I hope he's not. But I don't know. And it's just something to try to stir people's minds. It was never intended to hurt feelings or to offend anybody." read more »

Posted In

Os Guinness on Civility

Will Hinton's picture

I am in the midst of reading Os Guinness's new book, The Case for Civility. I have had high expectations for this book and so far I am not disappointed. In my mind, Guinness is the foremost expert of this topic, which is too often misunderstood. He makes this point in the first chapter.

"This short essay is a proposal for restoring civility in America, as one model for fostering civility around the world and helping to make the world safe for diversity. But civility must truly be restored. Is it not to be confused with niceness and mere etiquette or dismissed and squeamishness about differences. It is a tough, robust, substantive concept that is a republican virtue, critical to both democracy and civil society, and a manner of conduct that will be decisive for the future of the American republic." read more »

Posted In

Conversation about "Faith in the Halls of Power" with Michael Lindsay - Part 2

Will Hinton's picture

Here is Part 2 of the conversation between Glenn Lucke and Michael Lindsay. Part 1 can be found here.

GL: In Chapter 1, Presidents and Politics, you write that Bill Clinton and Al Gore are Southern Baptist evangelicals. They beat incumbent President George H. W. Bush in 1992, but you also state that 63% of evangelicals voted for the mainline Episcopalian Bush against these two Southern Baptists. read more »

Posted In

Conversation about "Faith in the Halls of Power" with Michael Lindsay - Part 1

Will Hinton's picture

My good friend Glenn Lucke sent me this excellent interview that he has conducted over the past few months with noted sociologist Michael Lindsay (for the record, Glenn recently attained his Ph.D in Sociology from University of Virginia while working with James Davison Hunter; Glenn is also wicked smart). I read Michael's book back in the fall and while I wasn't blown away, the depth of research in the book is very impressive.

Below is Glenn's introduction along with the first half of the interview. I will post the second half of the interview tomorrow. I welcome all comments especially those from readers of Glenn's blog, Common Grounds Online.


Michael Lindsay, a sociologist at Rice University, recently published Faith in the Halls of Power: How Evangelicals Joined America’s Elite. The endorsements for this book demonstrate that historians and sociologists of American religion are taking Lindsay and his work seriously.

For this project, Lindsay interviewed 360 evangelical elites in business, politics, academia and entertainment/media. While his labors in this regard are impressive (it is difficult to get access to many of these leaders), and have garnered most of the publicity that I’ve seen, a greater strength of the book in my estimation is the vast amount of history, sociology and political science scholarship that Lindsay read and synthesized. The breadth and depth of Lindsay’s work commend it to specialists. read more »

Posted In

Os Guinness on The Religious Right

Will Hinton's picture

The author Os Guinness is one of my heroes and has greatly influenced my thoughts on politics and religion. In his new book, The Case for Civility: And Why Our Future Depends On It, Os get at the root of much of what I dislike about the Religious Right.

As one who believes that the call of Jesus is to a path of suffering that shuts the door to every form of victim-playing, I am angered by organizers of the Religious Right who play the victim card and appeal openly to Christian resentment. . . .

Do they not know that those who portray themselves as victims come to perceive themselves as victims and then to paralyze themselves as victims? . . . read more »

Posted In

Unintential Comedy: Thy Name is Rowan Williams

Will Hinton's picture

A friend of mine sent me this story this morning:

"Controversial: Dr Rowan Williams believes the introduction of Sharia law to Britain will help maintain social cohesion

The Archbishop of Canterbury has today said that the adoption of Islamic Sharia law in the UK is "unavoidable" and that it would help maintain social cohesion.

Rowan Williams told BBC Radio 4's World At One that the UK has to "face up to the fact" that some of its citizens do not relate to the British legal system.

He says that Muslims could choose to have marital disputes or financial matters dealt with in a Sharia court.

He says Muslims should not have to choose between "the stark alternatives of cultural loyalty or state loyalty". read more »

Posted In

Another Conscientious Objector in the Culture War

Will Hinton's picture

I received a great email this morning from my friend Lorraine Charles. More and more I am seeing friends who are tired of being considered a "foregone conclusion" as a vote for a particular party because of the group they belong to. I can very much relate to Lorraine's thoughts here.

Last weekend I had dinner with old friends I hadn’t seen in awhile. My mind was only half engaged though--I’m an election year enthusiast and to top it off, it was the night of the South Carolina primary. I tried to wait until at least our food was served, but shortly after the server took our order I blurted out, “so which candidate do you like best?” Their response was something to the effect of, “Huckabee—he’s a Christian”. As both my friends and I are “born-again”, Protestant, Bible-believing Christians, I guess I shouldn’t have been surprised at their response. Nonetheless, a strong sense of dismay and disappointment came over me. I did my best to smile and ask polite questions about their choice, but I became even more horrified during the conversation when I needed to explain that no, Barack Obama is not a Muslim. read more »

Posted In

Would clones have souls?

Expat Teacher's picture

So the recent news that scientists were able to clone primates has me thinking. Would clones have souls?

Christians believe that human life is valuable because it has an eternal soul that is designed to be in a right relationship with God. It is because humans have souls that we are different and, thus, killing of humans is immoral. However, animals don't have souls so killing them for meat, hides, etc. is morally acceptable.

So, if scientists created a clone, would that clone have a soul? If it had a soul, would there be anything wrong with creating it? If it didn't have a soul, would there be anything wrong with using it as a human-tissue repository? read more »

Posted In

unChristian: To Write Love On Her Arms

Will Hinton's picture

Last week I wrote this meme about some of the common perceptions of Christians and what Christians should be known for. This meme has spread quite a bit and while the perceptions differ, there is a common thread in what people say Christians should be known for. Love.

Too often Christians aren't known for love. They are known for making stances against things, protesting for "family values", and for showing anything but love for others.

Well I am sick and tired of hearing about Pat Robertson, Ann Coulter, James Dobson, or worse, Fred Phelps. They are no more representatives for Christians than Osama Bin Laden is for Muslims.

Today I'd like to highlight a friend of mine who people should think of when they think of Christians.

Last year Jamie Tworkowski found himself spending five days helping a girl that a treatment center wouldn't take and who was struggling with addiction, depression, and suicide. Since then, Jamie has accidentally founded a non-profit organization, To Write Love On Her Arms, to bring hope and help for young people dealing with depression, self-injury, and suicide. I'm not going to attempt to retell the story; Jamie has told this girl's story here. read more »

Posted In

Kant and the New Atheists

I appreciate Dinesh Dsouza's linking the New Atheism to the fallacy of the Enlightenment, but Kant is not an ally to revealed religion as he suggests. Kant did attempt to make room for faith against the Enlightenment skepticism of his day, but he accomplished this by putting faith in a completely separate room from science. Hardly anyone questions whether these two should be separated anymore, but that move made the objects of faith utterly unknowable to reason. It turned religion into a subjective sentiment.

Kant's noumena—reality as it is in itself before the human mind filters it through its categories—is no friend to revealed religion. read more »

Posted In

Gay Marriage and the Hypocrisy of the Religious Right

Will Hinton's picture

Yesterday I was listening to a piece on NPR about Fred Thompson's presidential campaign and how he was making sure that Republican audiences knew for sure that he is conservative enough. There was a mention of Thompson being adequately pro-life and adequately anti-gay rights to satisfy social conservatives and especially evangelical Christians.

I find this so troubling. No wonder the average person thinks that Christians are anti-homosexual and hypocritical.

I'm trying to think through how a typical evangelical Christian might view the issue of gay rights/gay marriage. Usually the thought process is through the lens of "family values" and cultural norms; that is, gay marriage will undermine the institution of marriage and it therefore bad for families and our society. read more »

UnChristian: The Meme

Will Hinton's picture

My friend Gabe Lyons has just co-authored a fantastic new book, UnChristian: What a New Generation Really Thinks about Christianity... and Why It Matters. In it he and David Kinnaman explore many of the negative opinions that people have about Christians. Not surprisingly they learned that many people think of Christians as being judgmental, hypocritical, anti-homosexual, too political, and sheltered. (Here is an interview I conducted with Gabe)

I'm curious as to what other impressions people have about Christians.

I'm going to tag five of my friends to write their four things about Christians: three negative perceptions and one thing that Christians should be known for. So here is my list:

1. Christians don't create anything original. They only mimic the world around them.
Just go in any Christian bookstore. You will see "sanctified" Christian books that are almost identical to books in B&N or Borders. You will see t-shirts that are rip offs of "secular" apparel, yet with Bible verses. There are even Christian workout clubs. Yet why is it that the Christian version of so many "secular" (I hate the word secular) items are so often totally lame?

2. Christians get offended at everything.
It seems like every day Christians are getting riled up about something - be it DisneyWorld, supposed persecution of Christians in America (puh-leeze!), or even cursing in the work place. Sometimes it feels like Christians disagree with the first part of the bumper-sticker that says "Christians Aren't Perfect, Just Forgiven".

3. Christians are just waiting to be "raptured up" and couldn’t care less about this world.
What with books like the Left Behind series telling Christians that this world is all going to burn and many Christians’ visible revulsion at being good stewards of the Earth, it is hard to think otherwise.

4. Christians should be known for their unfailing love for others.
By others, I don't mean other Christians. I mean all other people. Especially those that are hard to love. The poor. The sick. The widowed. The outcasts. The oppressed.

A few of my friends are doing this. My friend Chris Heurtz of Word Made Flesh helps the poorest of the poor around the world. My friend Jamie Tworkowski of To Write Love On Her Arms helps people suffering with depression and suicidal tendencies. And my friend Daniel of Meet Justice is working to stop child sex trafficking in Atlanta.

I'm tagging the following five people to answer "UnChristian: 4 Things About Christians" and link to the book to read more about this topic:
Joe Carter of Evangelical Outpost
David Wayne of Jollyblogger
Brother Maynard of Subversive Influence
Daniel Larison
Michael Spencer of InternetMonk

You don't have to be tagged to answer these questions. read more »

UnChristian: What a New Generation Thinks About Christianity and Why it Matters

Will Hinton's picture

This short clip highlights some of the findings in the new book, UnChristian: What a New Generation Thinks About Christianity and Why it Matters By David Kinnaman and Gabe Lyons. The real shame is that Christians are the ones who have unfortunately created these negative feelings.

I'd love to get the thoughts of my readers on this topic. Do these characterizations seems accurate? How about as it relates to Christians in politics?

Here is my interview with co-author Gabe Lyons.

Posted In

Church and state in America: trends

Joseph Knippenberg's picture

In my spare time, I’ve been reading Mark Noll’s America’s God, which I recommend highly to anyone who needs a 500+ page diversion.

In the course of arguing that evangelical churches--above all, Methodists and Baptists (especially the former)--contributed mightily to the creation of our national identity in the early republic, Noll offers some telling statistics. In 1840, there were some 18,000 post offices and 21,000 postal employees; there were roughly 10,000 Methodist clergy (and three times as many clergy altogether). read more »

Posted In

Mathematical Metaphors in Political Discourse

A friend of mine recently told a discussion group that he was amazed to find himself "squarely in the middle" amongst us on a political issue. Although he wasn't trying to claim the higher ground, I was taken by how his staking out the middle ground had that effect anyway. It led to this end-of-the-week rumination:

Even as he was amazed to find himself "squarely in the middle", so I am amazed at how deeply entrenched political discourse is in mathematical metaphors. In one sense, all language is metaphorical--I think this is a result of God revealing Himself through ectypal figures while He Himself is incomprehensible as archetype. However, what amazes me in this case is how the mathematical metaphor itself carries persuasive force.

One might trace this back to the Pythagoreans, who believed that all of reality could be reduced to mathematical relationships. The Pythagorean theorem was, for them, not simply a geometric truth; it was a metaphysical truth. In fact, it was a religious truth. The Pythagoreans had a significant influence on Plato and when regarding his Doctrine of the Forms, it is important to keep this influence in mind. Plato's Forms (or Ideals) are not cookie-cutter semblances of the material objects; they are closer to something like a form(ula). read more »

Posted In

False Prophets

Does believing that "God is on our side" make it easier for us to inflict pain and suffering on those perceived to be our enemies? If we think God sanctions violence, are we more likely to engage in violent acts?

Those questions were posed recently by Social psychologist Brad Bushman of the University of Michigan. You may be surprised by the results.

According to the studies, the resounding answer to both questions is "yes." Researcher Brad Bushman hypothesized that "exposure to a biblical description of violence would increase aggression more than a secular description of the same violence" and that "aggression would be greater when the violence was sanctioned by God than when it was not sanctioned by God." In the study, students read a description of the beating, raping, and murder, of a woman in ancient Israel. One half of the students read a version of the story that included an assertion that God commanded the friends of the woman to take revenge. The other half read a version that did not mention God sanctioning violence. One group was told the account came from the Bible while the other was told it came from an ancient scroll. When those involved in the study were then entitled to inflict punishment upon others, those who believed that God sanctioned the punishment were the most aggressive in inflicting punishment. The results held true in Brigham Young University, where 99% of those tested said they believe in God and the Bible, and in Vrije University in Amsterdam, Holland,, where half said they believed in God and only 27% believed in the Bible. read more »

Posted In

James Dobson Doesn't Think Fred Thompson Is A Christian

Will Hinton's picture

Ugh! James Dobson has become a lot like Pat Robertson and I don't mean that as a compliment. Yesterday while speaking to U.S. News & World Report reporter Dan Gilgoff, Dobson opined about presidential hopeful Fred Thompson.

"[But] I don't think he's a Christian; at least that's my impression," Dobson added, saying that such an impression would make it difficult for Thompson to connect with the Republican Party's conservative Christian base and win the GOP nomination.

I don't know that much about Fred Thompson, but what little I know doesn't really give me any sense about his faith. read more »

Posted In

Would Jesus podcast?

Expat Teacher's picture

We often don't talk about how technology and religion interact on GWH, so I hope this topic opens up some conversation on the topic.

My church here in DC is a big fan of using the most modern technologies to reach anyone they can. I'm certainly not against that. Jesus himself said to preach the gospel to all the nations. However, the more I look at modern technology, the more I wonder if they run counter to part of the Gospel message. Since the radio and television have pulled people from the public square for entertainment into their own homes, technology has progressed as a way to offer people more and more individualized entertainment and information options. The VCR supplanted the movie theater. The cell phone supplanted the fixed line phone. Even the Blackberry supplanted the desktop PC for e-mail. read more »

Posted In

Evangelicals don't care about the environment, damn it!

Expat Teacher's picture

The main reason I started Page 132 was that I completely agreed with Donald Miller's profound realization, "I felt like, by going to this particular church, I was a pawn for the Republicans. Meanwhile, the Republicans did not give a crap about the causes of Christ."

So I have been watching very closely the latest scuffle between The Old Guard (Dobson et al) and some emerging leaders of modern American evangelical Christianity. read more »

Posted In

Georgia Conservative Christians Converting to Catholicism

Will Hinton's picture

After reading this article in the AJC, I have concluded that Georgia House Speaker Glenn Richardson has converted to Roman Catholicism.

I was particularly interested in these comments from Richardson:

"As a general rule, most people go to church of whatever faith on Sunday," he said. "And we don't sell beer on Sundays. It's just one of those traditions. And I don't think Republicans are doing anything other than trying to very carefully measure if we want to put that out there and let the citizens end that tradition." read more »

Posted In